He Who Fights With Monsters, Book 1: Outworlder
The He Who Fights With Monsters series, Book 1Travis Deverell (writing as "Shirtaloon")
Aethon
Fiction, Adventure/Fantasy/Humor
** (Bad)
DESCRIPTION:
Jason Asano was an ordinary young Australian man, living an ordinary life, expecting nothing but an ordinary future... until he wakes up, naked and hairless, in a hedge maze and is attacked by an outsized killer hamster. Even stranger, he starts seeing visual overlays like controls in a role-playing game, complete with stats, a map, an inventory, and quests (such as killing the killer hamster). But this is all too real to be some sort of game, and it lasts far too long to be just a bad dream, even before he runs into the cannibals.
Somehow, Jason has been pulled into a magical world both like and unlike Earth, a world with monsters and inhuman races and adventurers aplenty. He even gains magical powers and skills that level through use. Like the three strangers whom he helps escape from the cannibal mage cult, he aspires to become an adventurer. But the first powers he learns have dark leanings, and his new familiar - a pack of potentially apocalyptic leeches who live in his bloodstream - isn't exactly warm and fuzzy. As he learns the ways of this new world and spreads Aussie attitude and goodwill wherever he goes, he can't help being a disruptive and potentially dangerous influence, and more than one of his new friends starts to wonder if this ordinary outworlder might actually have the seeds of evil within, waiting to sprout.
This edition includes the exclusive bonus story, "When Farrah Met Rufus": before Rufus, Gary, and Farrah became a team, they had a most inauspicious meeting during a zombie invasion.
REVIEW:
After having loved Dungeon Crawler Carl beyond all expectations, I was looking for something else to scratch that itch until the next installment appears, and I was told that this series would do that. Like DCC, it features an ostensible everyman who finds himself plunged into what's essentially a real life role-playing game. And... that's about it on the similarity scale, unfortunately for this book.
There's a feel, from the very beginning, that this story had little planning and was grown organically in real-time, a sense that the writer is only a few paragraphs ahead, discovering the tale just ahead of the reader following his trail of words. This is, of course, a perfectly legitimate way to concoct a story, though at some point revisions should enter into things to smooth out the rough edges and inconsistencies and tangents that ultimately go nowhere (or at the very least fix obvious errors like sentences that had no spaces between words or letters, which is the sort of thing that should be caught by whatever software did the formatting for the presses but inexplicably made it through into the hardcover I bought). In any event, it was early on, so I was willing to give the tale some leeway. Unfortunately, like the naked protagonist in the maze, the plot just sort of wanders around at random as bad things happen, Jason often making questionable decisions and quips that he evidently found amusing (and I only rarely agreed). Through inept blunders, I kept giving the story a chance. Through the introduction of characters who felt like immature clichés, I kept giving the story a chance. Through repeated passages (verbatim), through character and storyline sprawl and an increasing sense that there really wasn't a point to anything, I kept giving the story a chance. Through the oddly icky vibes of a man reveling in his own dark magic and gory rituals and battles while insisting he's a good guy, through the strange reliance on food-based descriptors for non-white people's skin tones, through the offputtingly male gaze when it came to portrayals of women, through it all, I kept giving this story more and more chances. I'd been assured that it picked up and I'd grow to enjoy Jason as much as I'd come to love Carl and Princess Donut. But Jason kept being utterly obnoxious, and the haphazard world around him kept warping itself to make that obnoxiousness into an asset (and even when it was a detriment, it was apparently somehow something I was supposed to find endearing), as being an average Australian somehow makes Jason the most fascinating thing the locals have encountered since baked bread.
The short story showed that it wasn't just Jason, but the overall writing and tone. Nobody acts like an adult, even in a life-and-death situation. The whole thing feels like it should have a made-for-TV soundtrack and possibly the coaxed applause of a live studio audience. I just never felt like there was any reason to care, like there were any stakes at all.
There was potential here, to be sure. It could've been fun and exciting... if I hadn't found Jason and everyone else so insufferable so often. And it was light and undemanding, which fit with how other things in my life have been siphoning off my energy and focus, so I could push ahead in this while I just couldn't engage with other books I'd picked up at the time. If it had been tightened up, or at the very least if someone had noticed that irritating formatting error that kept making it look like people were talkingveryfastbecausetherewerenospaces (if you think that was irritating to read just once in a short review, try encountering it repeatedly over 700+ pages), and which made me more prone to see the whole works as less than polished and look for more problems to pick at, it might have had something.
Supposedly, the story picks up after the first couple volumes, but that's time and energy I just don't want to invest after being so deeply disappointed here. I just kept thinking back to my experience with Dungeon Crawler Carl, how quickly that book established characters to care about and solid stakes and always seemed to know exactly what it was about and what it was building, often surprising me and gut-punching me simultaneously, compared to the frivolous and seemingly random antics of He Who Fights With Monsters, and I wonder just what comparison - beyond both being "litRPG" stories - one could really make between the two.
You Might Also Enjoy:
Dungeon Crawler Carl (Matt Dinniman) - My ReviewOff to Be the Wizard (Scott Meyer) - My Review
Magic and the Shinigami Detective (Honor Raconteur) - My Review
No comments:
Post a Comment