Tuesday, November 17, 2026

He Who Fights With Monsters, Book 1: Outworlder

He Who Fights With Monsters, Book 1: Outworlder

The He Who Fights With Monsters series, Book 1
Travis Deverell (writing as "Shirtaloon")
Aethon
Fiction, Adventure/Fantasy/Humor
** (Bad)

DESCRIPTION:

Jason Asano was an ordinary young Australian man, living an ordinary life, expecting nothing but an ordinary future... until he wakes up, naked and hairless, in a hedge maze and is attacked by an outsized killer hamster. Even stranger, he starts seeing visual overlays like controls in a role-playing game, complete with stats, a map, an inventory, and quests (such as killing the killer hamster). But this is all too real to be some sort of game, and it lasts far too long to be just a bad dream, even before he runs into the cannibals.
Somehow, Jason has been pulled into a magical world both like and unlike Earth, a world with monsters and inhuman races and adventurers aplenty. He even gains magical powers and skills that level through use. Like the three strangers whom he helps escape from the cannibal mage cult, he aspires to become an adventurer. But the first powers he learns have dark leanings, and his new familiar - a pack of potentially apocalyptic leeches who live in his bloodstream - isn't exactly warm and fuzzy. As he learns the ways of this new world and spreads Aussie attitude and goodwill wherever he goes, he can't help being a disruptive and potentially dangerous influence, and more than one of his new friends starts to wonder if this ordinary outworlder might actually have the seeds of evil within, waiting to sprout.
This edition includes the exclusive bonus story, "When Farrah Met Rufus": before Rufus, Gary, and Farrah became a team, they had a most inauspicious meeting during a zombie invasion.


REVIEW:

After having loved Dungeon Crawler Carl beyond all expectations, I was looking for something else to scratch that itch until the next installment appears, and I was told that this series would do that. Like DCC, it features an ostensible everyman who finds himself plunged into what's essentially a real life role-playing game. And... that's about it on the similarity scale, unfortunately for this book.
There's a feel, from the very beginning, that this story had little planning and was grown organically in real-time, a sense that the writer is only a few paragraphs ahead, discovering the tale just ahead of the reader following his trail of words. This is, of course, a perfectly legitimate way to concoct a story, though at some point revisions should enter into things to smooth out the rough edges and inconsistencies and tangents that ultimately go nowhere (or at the very least fix obvious errors like sentences that had no spaces between words or letters, which is the sort of thing that should be caught by whatever software did the formatting for the presses but inexplicably made it through into the hardcover I bought). In any event, it was early on, so I was willing to give the tale some leeway. Unfortunately, like the naked protagonist in the maze, the plot just sort of wanders around at random as bad things happen, Jason often making questionable decisions and quips that he evidently found amusing (and I only rarely agreed). Through inept blunders, I kept giving the story a chance. Through the introduction of characters who felt like immature clichés, I kept giving the story a chance. Through repeated passages (verbatim), through character and storyline sprawl and an increasing sense that there really wasn't a point to anything, I kept giving the story a chance. Through the oddly icky vibes of a man reveling in his own dark magic and gory rituals and battles while insisting he's a good guy, through the strange reliance on food-based descriptors for non-white people's skin tones, through the offputtingly male gaze when it came to portrayals of women, through it all, I kept giving this story more and more chances. I'd been assured that it picked up and I'd grow to enjoy Jason as much as I'd come to love Carl and Princess Donut. But Jason kept being utterly obnoxious, and the haphazard world around him kept warping itself to make that obnoxiousness into an asset (and even when it was a detriment, it was apparently somehow something I was supposed to find endearing), as being an average Australian somehow makes Jason the most fascinating thing the locals have encountered since baked bread.
The short story showed that it wasn't just Jason, but the overall writing and tone. Nobody acts like an adult, even in a life-and-death situation. The whole thing feels like it should have a made-for-TV soundtrack and possibly the coaxed applause of a live studio audience. I just never felt like there was any reason to care, like there were any stakes at all.
There was potential here, to be sure. It could've been fun and exciting... if I hadn't found Jason and everyone else so insufferable so often. And it was light and undemanding, which fit with how other things in my life have been siphoning off my energy and focus, so I could push ahead in this while I just couldn't engage with other books I'd picked up at the time. If it had been tightened up, or at the very least if someone had noticed that irritating formatting error that kept making it look like people were talkingveryfastbecausetherewerenospaces (if you think that was irritating to read just once in a short review, try encountering it repeatedly over 700+ pages), and which made me more prone to see the whole works as less than polished and look for more problems to pick at, it might have had something.
Supposedly, the story picks up after the first couple volumes, but that's time and energy I just don't want to invest after being so deeply disappointed here. I just kept thinking back to my experience with Dungeon Crawler Carl, how quickly that book established characters to care about and solid stakes and always seemed to know exactly what it was about and what it was building, often surprising me and gut-punching me simultaneously, compared to the frivolous and seemingly random antics of He Who Fights With Monsters, and I wonder just what comparison - beyond both being "litRPG" stories - one could really make between the two.


You Might Also Enjoy:

Dungeon Crawler Carl (Matt Dinniman) - My Review
Off to Be the Wizard (Scott Meyer) - My Review
Magic and the Shinigami Detective (Honor Raconteur) - My Review

Saturday, October 31, 2026

October Site Update

Is it a trick or a treat? The main Brightdreamer Books site has been updated with the month's three reviews.

(Okay, so it's not much of either... So sue me, I'm on a budget.)

Enjoy!

Thursday, October 29, 2026

How to Slay Dragons and Influence Peasants (Heidi Regan)

How to Slay Dragons and Influence Peasants: Life Lessons from an Unlicensed Seer

Heidi Regan
Heidi Regan, publisher
Fiction, Collection/Fantasy/Humor
**** (Good)

DESCRIPTION:

The kingdom of Ektopia is much like any other in the world. It has its good monarchs and bad ones, its allies and enemies (who often switch roles on a whim), its dragons and centaurs and magical gnomes who don't always get their spells right, its wizards who name themselves after their own foreseen deaths, and of course its share of prophecies so vague they're only useful in hindsight, if then. But there's a reason for that vagueness; for all that they claim they want the truth, few people like having spoilers for their future blurted out, and some get rather testy about it. When a young witch with the gift of foresight blurts out a prophecy to her wizard lover, he angrily and impulsively curses her to spend the next 400 years atop Mount Woe - and, just like that, she finds herself in a dank cave on a cold mountaintop, unable to climb back down.
Instead of succumbing to doom and gloom and insanity (well, not for more than a few months), the seer instead chooses to make cursed lemonade out of the cursed lemons life handed her, leveraging her gift for prophecy into a lucrative business... but always being careful to couch her visions and advice in stories and anecdotes, because she really would rather not be cursed onto yet another mountaintop, not when she's finally got her cave nice and comfortable. Here, she collects many of her greatest hits, helpfully annotated with lessons for the modern reader.


REVIEW:

I usually shift gears between books, so having recently finished John Scalzi's cotton candy puff piece Starter Villain, I'd hoped to dig into something meatier and darker. Unfortunately, life kept interrupting whenever I tried, and finally a battle with insomnia drove me online to spend some Amazon credits on something, anything, I could enjoy that might cajole an uncooperative brain into rest. I grabbed this title on a whim, having seen and enjoyed several of the actor/comedian author's online videos... and I wound up devouring over a third of it in a single binge, and the rest the next day. (Yes, I did eventually sleep in between.)
Regan's writing has shades of Douglas Adams or Terry Pratchett, but unlike them she's not trying to slide a sly, dark knife of sophisticated social commentary underneath the humor (though there are several digs scattered about for those who want to look for them). That's why the stories collected here succeed; they never try to be more than they are, never pretend to build to some grand or profound insight. Even the timelines of the tales are wibbly-wobbly; the narrator intentionally skirts this by claiming that seers perceive time differently than other people, and trying too hard to find logic or line up events in a strict chronology takes the fun out of it, a written rebuke to nitpickers along the lines of the Mystery Science Theater 3000 theme song's admonition to repeat to yourself that it's just a show and you should really just relax. That said, there is some humor in how tales get changed and twisted through later generations; an Emperor's New Clothes-like incident of royal public nudity is later remembered as a mere misunderstanding, or a bold monarch bucking trends, or a royal victim of peasant cruelty.
Like Regan's online videos, the stories here often start with familiar parts from folklore and fairy tales and general fantasy tropes - the poor woodcutter catching a talking fish, the search for a Chosen One, a village plagued by a monster, and so forth - but veer off in wild, hilariously unpredictable directions almost out of the gate. She gleefully twists expectations, creating characters you care just enough about to keep reading, who often are their own worst enemies as they trip themselves up on the paths to their destinies. None of the tales are direct retellings of ones I've seen online, often elaborating and filling out the story. The seer herself occasionally appears, as do a few other recurring characters, such as a multiheaded half dragon and a possible Chosen One who isn't sure he wants to give up chicken farming. I found myself snickering a fair bit, and laughing more than once. There were also some nicely human moments along the way, and lessons if you think stories need them to justify their existence (including the lesson that there aren't always lessons).
As with any story collection, some tales felt stronger than others, but there were no duds in the batch. I rather enjoyed this little jaunt on the humorous side of fantasy, and wouldn't mind reading more.


You Might Also Enjoy:

The Greatest Nobodies of History (Adrian Bliss) - My Review
The Dragons at Crumbling Castle (Terry Pratchett) - My Review
The Enchanted Forest Chronicles (Patricia C. Wrede) - My Review

Monday, October 19, 2026

Starter Villain (John Scalzi)

Starter Villain

John Scalzi
Tor
Fiction, Humor/Sci-Fi
*** (Okay)

DESCRIPTION:

Thirtysomething Charlie's life is going exactly nowhere, and he knows it. Once a journalist, he's now divorced and living in his late father's house, barely scraping by as a substitute teacher. Soon, he may not even have the house, with his half-siblings fighting to have him evicted. If not for his cat Hera, he'd be alone in the world. Then his estranged uncle dies and everything changes.
He had only ever seen Jake once, but knew he was reasonably wealthy as the owner of a national chain of parking garages - at least, that's what he and most other people thought. When one of Uncle Jake's business partners reaches out to him, insisting he host the memorial service, Charlie notices some very unusual things. The floral arrangements all have nasty, even threatening messages like "Not Soon Enough" and "Rot in Hell" with them. The "mourners" seem to only be there to confirm that it's Jake's body and he is, in fact, dead (apparently he faked it at least once before). Then his home is blown up by an intruder - and that's when Charlie learns just what Uncle Jake's real business was. It turns out the old man was a supervillain, complete with volcano lair and henchpeople and hyperintelligent gene-modified cat spies, and like it or not Charlie has inherited the role - and all the enemies that come with it.


REVIEW:

I was hoping for something light and fun when I picked this up, especially after my previous read, which turned into a dark, heavy slog. That much, Scalzi delivered on, with a helium balloon-light tale... but there's basically nothing else here beyond the somewhat silly concept of the name.
From the start, Charlie is a hapless everyman of minimal personality. Even his jobs, formerly a journalist and currently a substitute teacher, barely come into play. You could swap him out with pretty much anyone, and while I understand that this is the plot role of an "everyman" it still made him feel too generic and flat to really care about. He's there to be the straight man (clever dialogue notwithstanding) as all manner of strange characters and circumstances occur around him, leading him through the story in a state of perpetual affable befuddlement until he comes out the other side little different than he went in. Oh, once in a while he sort of does something that affects things (or maybe not; many punches are either pulled or rigged in advance, and even the concept of "villain" is watered down even as it slams the reader in the face with how truly out-of-a-James-Bond-film monstrous the ultra-wealthy and -powerful are in reality), but for the most part he's just along for the ride, unable to step off but not really driving the plot forward. Everyone around him handles thorny details and blunts the corners for him as he wanders through life as the unexpected heir to an empire, and though Scalzi throws a bunch of words on the page describing that empire, most of it doesn't really matter because it means next to nothing to Charlie or the plot. Or maybe that was just me struggling to care.
There's a lot of clever dialogue and quips and banter that's ultimately so much pointless yammering, quite often talking around the point or delaying plot progress with digressions that were meant to be humorous but grew tiring quickly. (I actually found myself thinking that the whole story might've played better as a graphic novel, so the speech bubbles could just carry the tale without bogging down in words describing the rest of events in the panels.) It takes over halfway through the book for anything with any real stakes that I could feel to come into play, and even then Charlie was so hand-held and coddled by the plot and even his ostensible enemies that I really couldn't feel the peril or stakes; even comedy needs something like stakes, a reason to care about what happens, or it's just a string of vaguely amusing occurrences. By the end it becomes clear just how little Charlie or anything else I'd read ultimately mattered in how anything plays out, so there seemed minimal point to the whole digression in his unassuming and forgettable life... much like the experience of reading Starter Villain. It made be chuckle a bit as I read it, but it left no lasting impression.


You Might Also Enjoy:

Whales on Stilts (M. T. Anderson) - My Review
The Kaiju Preservation Society (John Scalzi) - My Review
Hench (Natalie Zina Walschots) - My Review

Monday, October 12, 2026

By Blood, By Salt (J. L. Odom)

By Blood, By Salt

The Land of Exile series, Book 1
J. L. Odom
Azimuth
Fiction, Fantasy
**+ (Bad/Okay)

DESCRIPTION:

Azelta has been a debt soldier, a veritable slave, for thirteen years, assigned to the Maurowan imperial army company of the Black Wrens. His crime? Being a penniless, homeless boy in a Maurowan city - and being a "jackal," as the Mashevi people are known. Many desert cultures have been cast under Emperor Riada's shadow and those of the bloodthirsty Maurowan gods, but the Mashevi had the audacity to resist, if unsuccessfully. Now, even though Azelta has proven himself an exemplary soldier and earned the captain's trust, even allowed to wear a blade (normally forbidden for jackals), he will never be a full person, never be a citizen, not even after finishing out his debt sentence in seven more years. He will always and forevermore be just a jackal, a subhuman... unless he takes a bold chance at something more.
No empire is without political struggle and rivalry, and the Maurowans are no different. The Emperor's quiet brother has become a nexus of rumor and speculation by those who would oust Riada, a focus of brewing rebellion, and those forces have reached the Black Wren. Riada now wishes to quell all questions of his might and the power of the crown (and their gods) by sending soldiers into the wild southern reaches of the Sahr to capture a "jinn," one of the rumored devil creatures said to dwell there, which even the native cultures fear. If Maurowans can capture a devil, if the empire can prove it can dominate even these monsters, surely none will question their righteous, divine rule ever again. But the jinn the Black Wrens finally capture is nothing at all like anyone expects - and in it Azelta sees the opportunity he has waited over a decade to find.


REVIEW:

I gave this a try because I was looking for something a bit different and I saw it recommended on a BookTube channel I was skimming. At first, it seemed to deliver that, an epic in the making with a richly realized setting and myriad intricate cultures that mix and (mostly) clash in numerous ways. The writing also had a somewhat poetic overtone, with frequent intriguing turns of phrase. If it seemed to be taking its own sweet time getting to anything like what the back cover promised in the way of a plot, and if the characters seemed far more defined by whom they hated and dehumanized and plotted against and the faiths they clung to (or considered blasphemous)... well, it was early on, and surely I'd grow to, if not love, at least be invested in the fate of someone.
I kept waiting for that investment to materialize. Given the rating, it's not much of a spoiler to say that it never did.
The author draws on their background as a linguist and experiences as a serving Marine to create some truly impressive cultural work. Each character sees almost a different world from their points of view, often lowering those of other cultures to mere "its" rather than men or women. Even those who are cordial with Azelta are too ready to slip back into calling him a "jackal" and ask him to keep his head down and bide his time and maybe someday he'll earn the respect that the vast majority of the world will never give him because of his accent and skin tone and beliefs and all the other markers that show him to be a despised Mashevi. Even other cultures that have been stomped down by the Maurowan empire (and as an aside, I really struggled at the start with how similarly "Mashevi" and "Maurowan" scanned) hate the jackals, seemingly above and beyond all other peoples of the desert, with the exception of the "jinn" of the Sahr, a race so secretive and hated that they're made out to be literal devils. How burdened Azelta is, how stiffly loyal to the nebulous god of his people (the only one that only goes by God, oddly enough) and the customs of a culture he has been isolated from for the majority of his life, how unjust the whole world is to him in particular, yet see how he perseveres and bites down on the bitterness, how superior he surely is in spirit to the men surrounding him. (And it is almost exclusively men; there are only a few women involved at all, and of them they serve basically no purpose and seem utterly forgotten about by the end - save one, the Sahr "jinn," who is a cunning and selfish and devious being and possibly the only one more tormented than Azelta, though specifics of her origins and goals are maddeningly vague... and it's strongly implied that, if she really is a "devil" and "damned," then of course she must've deserved it.)
In any event, things slowly meander up to the expedition to the Sahr lands, which has some nicely stark and tense moments even before they encounter the hostile natives... and then they actually capture the "jinn" and the tale bogs right back down again, going back to wallowing in misery and the many clashing cultures, pretty much all of whom hate everyone else for not being like themselves and only are "friends" so long as they can use a body, if that long.
Throughout, the author plays their cards far too close to their chest on several accounts, shutting me out from too much and preventing me from actually caring about anyone or wanting them to succeed. While the players could be interesting initially, I eventually found them more frustrating than intriguing, especially when I was clearly not being allowed enough information to figure out why any of it could possibly matter. So what if the coup succeeds or fails? So what if Azelta is executed for impunity or not? So what if the Sahr woman is actually a damned soul who only wants to confront the god or gods who cursed her... or maybe not? Toward the very end were a few revelations that would've meant a lot more if they'd been built up properly, but the little buildup had happened way at the beginning of the book, so I'd long forgotten about it and had to do some mental backtracking to figure out why I should find the revelations important. It's like springing the punchline to a joke several days after offhandedly muttering about chickens crossing roads; by the time the listener even remembers the question, the laugh just isn't really going to be there. And by the conclusion the whole thing had taken certain plot turns that made me suspect that it had been intended to be more religious fiction than the fantasy epic I'd thought it was (something about a tormented potential leader of a scattered culture persistently placing faith in the only deity named "God" among packs of idol-worshipping heathens seeking specifically to oppress and exterminate the faithful... but maybe I'm reading too much into it, perhaps for lack of actually finding specific in-book characters or things to hold my interest long enough to maintain suspension of disbelief and separation from my own world).
It's this last point, the sense of bait-and-switch, that ultimately sank the rating below the flat Okay. While I could appreciate the detailed cultures created and how each person had their own particular beliefs and moralities reflected in their chapters, I just felt alienated by all the backstabbing and front-stabbing and general, seemingly insurmountable prejudices and hatred that soured everyone and everything. The whole lot of them could've been swept off the map in a sandstorm and it would've made the tale much brighter. (And, seriously, would it have killed the author to write one woman who actually mattered and wasn't implied to be literally cursed and damned by whatever god or gods ruled the world? Why bother including female characters at all, if that's all they are?)


You Might Also Enjoy:

Dune (Frank Herbert) - My Review
A Memory Called Empire (Arkady Martine) - My Review
The Thousand Names (Django Wexler) - My Review